If you're in the market for a used pickup truck, reliability is likely a top concern. With warranty coverage often expired, choosing a model known for longevity is crucial to avoid costly repairs. Consumer Reports has analyzed its latest reliability survey data to compile a list of the most reliable used pickup trucks it recommends.
The Ford Maverick, despite its unibody construction and smaller size, earns a spot for its proven reliability, though the 2022 model year is best avoided. The Honda Ridgeline is praised for its thoughtful design and daily usability, with recommended model years including 2009, 2013, and 2020-2023.
Hyundai's Santa Cruz, a crossover-based truck, offers comfort and has shown reliability comparable to the Maverick, with the 2024 and 2025 models being solid choices. For a traditional body-on-frame truck, the Nissan Frontier (recommended years: 2015-2019, 2024-) is noted for its mechanical dependability, with common complaints being minor paint or trim issues.
Finally, the Toyota Tacoma, while in high demand, has a mixed reliability record with some HVAC and driveline issues reported. For better reliability, Consumer Reports suggests considering older Toyota Tundra models. The list serves as a guide for used truck buyers seeking confidence in their purchase.