The Philosophy Behind the Picks

After decades of testing hundreds of vehicles, automotive content creator Doug DeMuro has curated a definitive list of the nine cars that offer the most compelling driving experiences. His selection criteria heavily favored mid-engine configurations, prioritizing mechanical balance, emotional resonance, and overall composure on the road.


While financial accessibility varied greatly across his choices, the focus remained strictly on the visceral feeling behind the wheel rather than the price tag.


The Selection of Excellence

DeMuro’s list traverses a vast spectrum of automotive history and engineering:


  • B5 Audi RS 4 Avant: Regarded as a significant improvement over its predecessor, the RS 2, this model won DeMuro over with its smooth V6 turbo engine and responsive handling. At approximately $27,900, it stands out as a highly approachable performance value.
  • Lamborghini Countach: Celebrated for its vintage allure and distinctive character, the Countach remains a legendary experience, though it comes with a premium price tag often exceeding $1 million.
  • Pagani Zonda: DeMuro highlights the Zonda’s refined transmission and structural balance. According to market data for the Zonda Revolucion, expect an investment of around $2.8 million.
  • Honda S2000: Often described by DeMuro as feeling like a nimble, compact "thimble," this car provides a pure, mechanical connection between driver and machine, priced around $25,000 for a 2000 model.
  • FD Mazda RX7: Offering the precision and joy of a lightweight sports car without compromise, the rare FD generation is highly sought after, with prices for a 1993 model averaging around $74,900.
  • McLaren P1 GTR: As the only automatic on the list, this hypercar is praised for its immense power and razor-sharp steering. DeMuro likened the experience to a "personal rollercoaster."
  • 992 Porsche 911 ST: Praised for its perfect equilibrium and aggressive yet controllable nature, this modern icon is estimated to cost between $649,900 and $699,992.
  • Porsche Carrera GT: Frequently cited as a masterclass in precision, this mid-engine legend allows for surgical driving control. Used models can reach prices near $669,000.
  • Ferrari F50: Taking the top spot, the F50 is lauded by DeMuro for its surprising nimbleness and sheer emotional driving impact. It remains the ultimate benchmark, with market values ranging between $5.8 million and $9.1 million.

"If I could swap my Carrera GT for an F50, I would do it," DeMuro remarked regarding his top pick. "Dollar for dollar, they are not the same price, but if they were I would do it in a heartbeat."